It’s a question every frustrated employee and capable manager has asked: How can someone who doesn’t know how to manage continue to climb the ranks? The question is not about preference or leadership style. It’s about not achieving results and involuntary attrition.
The answer is rarely luck, coincidence, or blind chance. In many organizations, it’s deliberate, even if subconscious.
Organizations can, consciously or unconsciously, cultivate weak management, resulting in a deliberate culture of mediocrity. In these systems, titles matter more than skills, and visibility, comfort, obedience, and loyalty are valued above true managerial competence. The goal isn’t excellence, but safety for the system.
The mechanism is simple: weak managers are not afraid of failure, but of exposure. A manager with real skill, confidence, and initiative is a threat as they shine a light on gaps, demand accountability, and challenge the status quo, despite commonly and publicly expressing the need for people who do exactly that. That kind of presence disrupts the protective shell that weak management builds around itself.
To survive and thrive, weak organizations develop compensatory mechanisms:
- Loyalty over skill: People are rewarded for keeping their heads down, following instructions, and not questioning decisions.
- Obedience over creativity: Initiative is risky, but compliance is safe.
- Comfort over challenge: Problems are ignored or delayed to avoid friction.
These mechanisms form a self-protecting structure. Each layer in the hierarchy shields the one above it. Managers who might expose incompetence or try to work around it are systematically filtered out. The system doesn’t fail because it is poorly designed. It succeeds in one narrow sense that is not necessarily beneficial to the organization – it preserves the existing power structure.
The consequences are predictable: capable managers leave or never rise, leaving mediocrity to perpetuate itself. The organization ends up rewarding silence over insight, presence over performance, and loyalty over leadership. Over time, true managerial depth becomes rare, not by accident, but by design.
This uncomfortable situation is not an anomaly. It is an emergent property of a system that values safety over skill, even in startups that started as a disruption.
Breaking weak management
A leader who wants genuine capability in their ranks must redefine what gets rewarded. Skillful management, the courage to speak up, and the ability to drive results must become visible, valued, and safe. Anything less guarantees that mediocrity will continue to climb while real leaders get pushed out. You can find more about this inattention to results in The Five Dysfunctions of a Team and seeing reality as it is in Good to Great.
As a leader, your job is to achieve results and retain your people. As an executive, you’re also expected to grow the next leaders. To be effective, you need to constantly build trust, give feedback, coach and delegate.
Notice what you reward.
Leave a Reply